● Running the firm

Security Questions to Ask an Accounting Outsourcing Vendor

A due-diligence checklist of security and confidentiality questions CPA firms should ask accounting outsourcing and software vendors before sharing client data.

By , Global Tax SpecialistUpdated 6 min read

01Why vendor security is your responsibility

When you share client data with an outsourcing provider or a software vendor, the obligation to protect it does not move with the data. Tax and accounting firms handle some of the most sensitive information there is, and they are subject to data security requirements, including keeping a written information security plan. Professional standards also generally require confidentiality arrangements with third-party service providers.

Before any client data is shared, ask questions, ask for evidence and record the answers.

02The questions

Governance

  • Do you have a documented information security program, and who owns it?
  • How often is it reviewed?
  • Can you share your security materials or an independent assessment report?
  • Do you have a written information security plan, and does it cover the services you will provide to us?

People

  • Are staff background-checked, where the law allows?
  • Do staff sign confidentiality agreements?
  • What security training do they receive, and how often?
  • Will the same named people work on our clients?

Access control

  • Does every person have an individual account? Are shared logins prohibited?
  • Is multi-factor authentication required?
  • Is access limited to the clients and systems each person needs?
  • How quickly is access removed when someone leaves or changes role?
  • Can we see an access log for our clients?

Devices and networks

  • Are work devices company-managed, encrypted and kept up to date?
  • Can data be copied to personal devices or USB drives?
  • How do staff connect to our systems: through our tools, a secure channel or their own?

Data location and handling

  • Where is our data stored and processed, by country and provider?
  • Is data encrypted in transit and at rest?
  • Do you use subprocessors, and will you tell us about changes?
  • How long do you keep our data, and how is it deleted?

AI providers

  • Which AI services process our data?
  • Do the providers' terms allow them to train models on our data?
  • Can AI features be turned off for specific clients?
  • Are AI outputs reviewed by a person before use?

Tax-specific questions

  • Will any tax return information be disclosed to people outside the United States?
  • If so, how do you support our taxpayer consent process and the limits on Social Security numbers? See Section 7216 consent when outsourcing.
  • How are client documents transferred to you: a portal, our systems or email?

Incidents

  • How do you detect and respond to security incidents?
  • How quickly will you notify us, and what information will you provide?
  • Have you had a security incident affecting client data in recent years?

Exit

  • How will you return or delete our data if we end the relationship?
  • How do you confirm that access has been removed?

03Red flags

  • Shared logins or reluctance to set up individual accounts.
  • No written security program or plan.
  • Vague answers about where data is stored.
  • Client documents sent by personal email.
  • No clear answer about AI providers and training.
  • Unwillingness to put confidentiality and data handling in the agreement.

04Put it in the agreement

Turn the answers into contract terms: confidentiality, permitted use of data, subcontracting, data location, breach notification, audit rights and return or deletion at the end. See white-label bookkeeping for CPA firms for the other topics an agreement should cover.

05Review every year

Ask the same questions annually and whenever the vendor's services change. Keep the answers with your own written information security plan.

06What good answers look like

Questions are only useful if you can judge the answers. Some examples:

QuestionWeak answerStronger answer
How is access controlled?"Only our staff can see your data.""Each person has an individual account with multi-factor authentication, limited to your clients. Access is reviewed monthly and removed within one working day of a role change."
Where is data stored?"In the cloud.""In named cloud regions with a named provider. Here is our list of subprocessors."
Do you use AI?"Yes, it's secure.""These AI providers process data for these features. Their terms do not allow training on your data. You can turn the features off per client."
What happens in an incident?"We have never had one.""We have a documented response plan and will notify you within an agreed time with what happened, what data was affected and what we are doing."

Ask for documents that back up the stronger answers.

07Evidence to request

  • A summary of the security program and the written information security plan.
  • Any independent assessment report the vendor holds, and its scope.
  • The list of subprocessors and where they operate.
  • The incident response and notification process.
  • Standard confidentiality and data processing terms.

08A simple vendor scoring method

Score each area from one to three:

  1. Governance and documentation
  2. People and training
  3. Access control
  4. Devices and networks
  5. Data location and handling
  6. AI providers
  7. Tax-specific controls and consent
  8. Incidents and exit

A vendor scoring one in any area needs a fix before you share data. Record the scores with the evidence, and rescore each year.

09After you sign

Due diligence is not a one-time event:

  • Review access lists for your clients regularly.
  • Ask for updates when the vendor adds subprocessors or AI features.
  • Remove access promptly when people or clients change.
  • Rerun the questions annually and file the answers with your own security plan.

10How Marksford handles security

Our security page describes the controls Marksford can document, including access, data location, AI providers and consent, and you can request our security materials before sharing any client data. Dedicated staff work in your systems through a secure channel agreed with you; see hire dedicated staff. We only describe controls that are in place.

FAQFrequently asked questions

How often should I review a vendor's security?

At least once a year, and whenever the vendor changes its services, subprocessors or AI features, or when you expand the work you give them.

What documents should a vendor provide?

A summary of its security program, its written information security plan, any independent assessment report and its scope, a list of subprocessors, its incident response process and its confidentiality and data processing terms.

Should software vendors get the same questions as outsourcing providers?

Mostly yes. Software vendors store and process your client data too. Focus extra attention on data location, AI providers, access by the vendor's own staff, and what happens to your data when you leave.

What if a vendor will not answer?

Treat a refusal to document controls as a serious warning sign. Do not share client data until you have answers you can rely on.

What should I ask an accounting outsourcing vendor about security?

Ask about their security program, staff vetting and training, access control, devices, where data is stored, AI providers, incident response, tax-specific consent, and how data is returned or deleted at the end.

Is my firm responsible for data a vendor handles?

Your firm generally remains responsible for protecting client data, which is why due diligence, contract terms and ongoing review matter.

Do I need a written information security plan?

Tax and accounting firms are generally required to maintain one under federal data security rules. It should cover how you oversee service providers.

What are the red flags in vendor security?

Shared logins, no written security program, vague answers about data location, client data sent by personal email and unclear AI data use.

→Tools for this topic

This guide is general information for accounting professionals. It is not legal, tax or accounting advice. Marksford is not a CPA firm.

● Get started

Want this handled for your firm?

Book a call and we will show you how Marksford fits the way your firm works.

  • Your brand stays the face of the firm
  • Your partner keeps the final approval
  • We aim to have you live in 7 days, depending on scope
Prefer to test first? Run a side-by-side pilot

Book your strategy call

Tell us about your firm. We will be in touch to arrange the call.

No commitment. We use your details only to arrange the call. See our Privacy Policy.