01Hourly or fixed monthly fees?
| Hourly billing | Fixed monthly fee | |
|---|---|---|
| Client experience | Unpredictable bills | One predictable price |
| Effect of efficiency | Faster work earns less | Faster work earns more |
| Scope control | Easy to bill extra | Needs a clear scope |
| Planning | Hard to forecast | Easy to forecast |
Most firms that grow their bookkeeping practice move to fixed monthly fees per client. The fee is set from the expected effort and adjusted when the scope changes. Hourly billing still has a place for one-off projects with uncertain scope.
02What drives the price
When you set a client's monthly fee, look at the factors that drive effort:
- Transaction volume. The number of bank and card transactions each month.
- Number of accounts. Each bank, card and loan account needs reconciling.
- Payroll. Whether you post payroll journals, and how many employees.
- Receivables and payables. Whether you manage invoicing or bills.
- Inventory and job costing. These add complexity.
- Frequency. Monthly, quarterly or annual.
- Quality of records. Clients who send documents late or keep poor records cost more to serve.
- Reporting. Standard statements versus custom reports, budgets or class tracking.
03Building tiers
Two or three tiers make pricing simple to explain:
| Tier | Typical scope |
|---|---|
| Essential | Monthly categorisation and bank reconciliations, basic profit and loss and balance sheet, up to a set number of transactions and accounts |
| Standard | Everything in Essential, plus payroll journals, accruals and prepaids, variance notes and a close memo |
| Advanced | Everything in Standard, plus receivables and payables management, class or location reporting and a monthly review call |
Define each tier by scope and limits, and state what happens when a client goes over: a move to the next tier, or a per-unit charge.
04Price catch-up and clean-up separately
Backlog months and messy books take far more time than a normal month. Quote catch-up work as a separate project, priced per month of backlog or as a fixed fee after a quick assessment, then start the monthly fee once the books are current.
05Know your cost per client
Price from your cost, not just from competitors. For each tier, estimate:
- Preparation time, in-house or outsourced.
- Review time from your senior staff.
- Client communication time.
- Software costs, such as the ledger, AI bookkeeping, document extraction, portal and workflow tools.
- Overhead allocated per client.
Add your target margin. If you use outsourced preparation or white-label bookkeeping, per-client provider pricing makes this calculation straightforward; see white-label bookkeeping for CPA firms.
06Presenting the price
- Present the tiers side by side, with your recommendation.
- Explain the scope in plain language, including what is not included.
- State the monthly fee and the billing period clearly.
- Put the scope and fee in the engagement letter.
07Review prices every year
Once a year, compare the fee with the actual effort for each client. Clients whose volume has grown should move tiers; clients who are consistently late with documents may need a fee change or a conversation. A shared board with time and status for each close, see tracking review stages, makes this review much easier.
08A worked example: pricing one client
Take an illustrative client with about 250 transactions a month, three bank and card accounts, a loan, and payroll for eight employees. The steps:
- Estimate effort. With good processes and AI-drafted categorisation, preparation, reconciliation and adjustments take a predictable number of hours a month. Add review time and client communication.
- Add tool costs. Software priced per client, such as an AI bookkeeping tool and a client portal, is added directly. Seat-priced tools are allocated across clients.
- Add outsourced cost, if preparation is outsourced, at the provider's per-client price.
- Add overhead, such as rent, insurance and administration, allocated per client.
- Add margin. Your target margin on top of cost.
- Place the client in a tier. This client fits the Standard tier: payroll journals, accruals and variance notes included.
The output is a single monthly fee you can explain and defend, and that improves your margin as your process gets faster.
09Handling scope changes
Clients change. Set rules up front:
- Volume grows past the tier's limit for three consecutive months: move to the next tier, with notice.
- New accounts or entities are added to the scope with a price change.
- One-off projects, such as a loan application package or a system migration, are quoted separately.
- Late documents that cause rework may carry a fee, if your engagement letter says so.
Write these rules into the engagement letter so changes are a formality, not a negotiation.
10Value-based extras
Many clients will pay more for things that help them run their business:
- A monthly review call to go through the numbers.
- Cash flow forecasting.
- Budget versus actual reporting.
- Key performance indicators for their industry.
These sit on top of the bookkeeping fee and are where firms earn the most for their expertise.
11Mistakes to avoid
- Pricing below cost to win the client, hoping to raise prices later.
- Tiers so detailed that clients cannot compare them.
- Ignoring review time when calculating cost.
- Never raising prices as clients grow.
12How Marksford's pricing works
Marksford prices every product by the unit, so costs follow use: Workflow per team member, Books and ClientBase per client, and DocPrism per document. Services such as bookkeeping and close are quoted per client or engagement. You can estimate your monthly cost with the estimator on our pricing page.
FAQFrequently asked questions
How do I move existing hourly clients to fixed fees?
Look at the last six to twelve months of hours for each client, place them in a tier, and explain the change as a benefit: one predictable price and no surprise bills. Give notice and put the new scope in an updated engagement letter.
Should bookkeeping be priced by transaction count?
Transaction count is a good proxy for effort, so many firms use it to set tier limits. Combine it with the number of accounts, payroll and reporting needs rather than pricing on transactions alone.
How do software costs affect bookkeeping prices?
Software priced per client or per unit can be built directly into each client's fee. Seat-priced software should be spread across clients. Either way, include it in your cost before adding margin.
What margin should a bookkeeping practice aim for?
It varies by firm and market. What matters is that the margin covers review time and growth, and that it improves as your process becomes more efficient.
Should I charge hourly or a fixed fee for bookkeeping?
Most firms do better with a fixed monthly fee per client based on scope, because it is predictable for the client and rewards efficiency. Hourly billing suits one-off projects with uncertain scope.
What factors affect bookkeeping pricing?
Transaction volume, number of accounts, payroll, receivables and payables work, inventory, frequency, reporting needs and the quality of the client's records.
How should I price catch-up bookkeeping?
As a separate project, priced per month of backlog or as a fixed fee after assessing the records, before the monthly fee begins.
How often should I review bookkeeping prices?
At least once a year, comparing each client's fee with the actual effort and moving clients between tiers where needed.
→Tools for this topic
→Related guides
This guide is general information for accounting professionals. It is not legal, tax or accounting advice. Marksford is not a CPA firm.