01Why retyping is the problem
Every tax season, preparers type thousands of figures from PDFs, phone photos and scanned paper into tax software. Each typed figure is a chance for a transposed digit, a missed box or a figure entered against the wrong payer, and each one then has to be checked again in review. Retyping is slow, error-prone and adds no judgement.
Extraction moves people from typing to checking.
02The documents that extract well
| Document | Typical fields extracted |
|---|---|
| Form W-2 | Employer and EIN, employee, wages (box 1), federal tax withheld (box 2), Social Security and Medicare wages and tax (boxes 3–6), box 12 codes, state wages and tax (boxes 16–17) |
| Form 1099-INT and 1099-DIV | Payer, interest, dividends, qualified dividends, tax withheld |
| Form 1099-B | Proceeds, cost basis, dates, short or long term, wash sales |
| Form 1099-NEC and 1099-MISC | Payer, nonemployee compensation, other income |
| Form 1099-R | Gross distribution, taxable amount, distribution code |
| Form 1098 | Lender, mortgage interest, points, property tax where reported |
| Schedule K-1 | Entity, partner or shareholder share of income, deductions and credits |
Consolidated brokerage statements and K-1s are longer and less uniform, so expect more fields to need a person.
03Four ways to get data out of tax documents
- Manual entry. Accurate when people are careful, but slow and hard to scale.
- Downloads and imports. Some payers and brokers provide data you can import directly. Use it where available; it is often the most reliable source.
- Basic OCR. Turns an image into text, but does not know which number is box 1 and which is box 2. Useful, but needs heavy checking.
- Document intelligence. Classifies the document type, reads fields by meaning, scores confidence and links each figure to its location on the page.
For most firms, the best approach combines imports where they exist with document intelligence for everything else.
04How good extraction works
- Classify. Recognise the document as, for example, a 2026 W-2 rather than a 2025 W-2 or a pay stub.
- Extract. Read each field and its value.
- Score. Attach a confidence score to each field.
- Link. Record the page and position where each figure came from.
- Validate. Run checks before a person sees the document.
- Route. Send low-confidence fields to a person to verify, with the source highlighted.
05The validation checks to run
- Tax year matches the engagement. A prior-year W-2 uploaded by mistake is one of the most common errors.
- Recipient matches the client. The name and identifying details should match the taxpayer or spouse.
- Formats are valid. Identification numbers, dates and amounts in the expected format.
- Totals tie. Boxes that should relate, such as Social Security wages and tax, should be consistent.
- No duplicates. The same document uploaded twice should be caught.
- Statements balance. For bank and brokerage statements, opening balance plus activity should equal closing balance.
06What to do with low-confidence fields
Never accept a low-confidence field silently. Route it to a person with the page open and the field highlighted, so they can confirm or correct it in seconds. Once verified, record who confirmed it. Over time you will see which payers and document types cause the most uncertainty, often blurry photos and unusual layouts, and you can ask clients for better copies.
07Handling the data safely
Tax documents contain highly sensitive information, including Social Security numbers. Make sure your extraction tool:
- Stores documents securely and limits who can access them.
- Keeps an audit trail of who viewed and changed each field.
- Is clear about where data is processed, and whether any AI provider may use it.
- Supports any consent requirements if data is processed or viewed outside the United States; see Section 7216 consent when outsourcing.
08How it fits into the tax workflow
Extraction works best as part of a connected flow: clients upload through a portal against a checklist, documents are extracted and checked, verified figures flow to preparation, and every figure in the workpaper links back to its source. Read how to cut retyping during tax season for the full process and outsourced tax preparation for how review works.
09A worked example: one W-2, start to finish
- Upload. A client photographs a W-2 with their phone in the firm's portal. The app straightens and crops the image.
- Classify. The document is recognised as a 2026 Form W-2.
- Extract. The employer, EIN, employee name and boxes 1 to 17 are read. Box 1 wages of $84,210.00 are extracted with high confidence; box 17 state tax of $3,702.55 has lower confidence because the photo is slightly blurred in that corner.
- Validate. The tax year matches the engagement, the employee matches the client, and the Social Security and Medicare figures are consistent with the wages.
- Route. Box 17 goes to a preparer with the corner of the image highlighted. The preparer confirms the figure in a few seconds.
- Link. Every figure carries a link to its position on the page. When the reviewer later asks where state tax came from, one click opens the highlighted source.
The preparer typed nothing and checked one field.
10Tips for better extraction results
- Ask for originals where possible. Downloaded PDFs from employers and brokers extract better than photos.
- Guide clients on photos. Flat surface, good light, whole page in frame. A camera flow with edge detection helps.
- Group multi-page documents. Consolidated brokerage statements should be uploaded as one file, not page by page.
- Use last year's payers. Knowing which documents to expect makes classification and missing-document checks more reliable.
- Review confidence settings. Adjust the threshold for sending fields to a person based on what your reviewers find.
11Handling the hard documents
Some documents need more care:
- Consolidated 1099s from brokers can run to dozens of pages, with summary and detail sections. Extract the summary figures and check them against the detail.
- Schedule K-1s vary by issuer and often include supplemental statements. Expect more fields to need a person, and always read the footnotes.
- Corrected forms must replace the original, not be added to it. Check for "corrected" markings.
- Handwritten or old forms are better entered by a person.
12Measuring the benefit
Track, for a sample of returns:
- Fields extracted automatically versus entered by hand.
- Fields that needed verification.
- Errors found in review that trace back to data entry.
- Time from complete documents to a prepared return.
These numbers show where extraction saves time and where it needs better inputs.
13How Marksford DocPrism helps
Marksford DocPrism reads W-2s, 1099s, K-1s, 1098s, statements, invoices and prior-year returns, extracts the figures and links each one to its source page. It checks tax year, formats, balances and recipients against your rules, and sends low-confidence fields to a person with the source highlighted. DocPrism is priced per document; see pricing. Documents can arrive through ClientBase.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Can software read W-2 and 1099 forms accurately?
Yes, for standard layouts it can extract most fields with high confidence. Fields with low confidence, blurry images or unusual layouts should be checked by a person.
What is the difference between OCR and document extraction?
OCR turns an image into text. Document extraction understands which value belongs to which field, scores its confidence and links it to its location on the page.
How do I check extracted tax data?
Run validation checks for tax year, recipient, formats and totals, then have a person verify any low-confidence fields with the source highlighted.
Can extraction handle K-1s and brokerage statements?
Yes, but they are longer and less uniform than W-2s, so more fields typically need a person to verify.
Is it safe to upload tax documents to extraction software?
It can be, if the vendor documents its security controls, limits access, keeps an audit trail and is clear about where data is processed.
→Tools for this topic
→Related guides
This guide is general information for accounting professionals. It is not legal, tax or accounting advice. Marksford is not a CPA firm.